Worthless?

Who is worse?

A) Someone who is shomer shabbos, keeps kosher, and davens with a minyan 3x a day, but who also thinks its asur to read a newspaper, study a secular subject, or get a job?
B) Someone who is secular, doesn't keep kosher or do any of the above, but thinks its ok to read a newspaper, study secular subjects, and have a job? And I mean for this person to be just as superficial (philosophically) as the first one.

And why

Update: What I meant to ask is, starting out as A), is it better to remain as A) or change to B)